FactCheckRadar Fact-check archive

Published fact-check

Did Israeli Soldiers Throw "Pancake Parties" Mocking Rachel Corrie?

Mixed

Claim checked

“And after killing her, they threw Pancake themed parties where they made pancakes celebrating "turning her into a pancake". The Israeli depravity you see on display today is not new. It is not something that started on Oct 7th. It is how the Israeli society has always been!”

Published

Verdict

Mixed

The claim that Israeli soldiers held "pancake themed parties" celebrating the killing of American activist Rachel Corrie is partially supported but significantly overstated. Reporting from 2013 confirms that photos were posted online showing soldiers at a Jerusalem settlement posing with pancakes under a caption referencing "Rachel Corrie pancakes," and the settlement's director defended the images. However, the evidence does not support the characterization of organized "parties" — it appears to have been a single photo post. The broader claim that this reflects how "Israeli society has always been" is an editorial generalization, not a verifiable factual claim.

Reasoning

The core factual question is whether Israeli soldiers actually made pancakes mocking Rachel Corrie's death. The Electronic Intifada, a pro-Palestinian news outlet, reported in July 2013 that photos appeared on the Facebook page of "Heritage House," a settlement in East Jerusalem housing overseas recruits serving in the Israeli military. The photos showed young men, some in military fatigues, with a caption reading "Afternoon of 'rachel corrie' Pancakes and fun!" The pun references the idiom "flat as a pancake," alluding to how Corrie was killed by a bulldozer in 2003. Islam Times subsequently picked up the story, and the Heritage House director, Ben Packer, responded to criticism by doubling down, calling the photos "even funnier" and pledging donations to settlements.

So the basic fact — that soldiers associated with Heritage House posted photos referencing "Rachel Corrie pancakes" — is documented. However, the viral post's language of "pancake themed parties" (plural) suggests multiple organized events, which the reporting does not substantiate. The evidence points to a single photo post on a Facebook page, not a series of celebrations. The broader editorial claim about "Israeli depravity" being inherent to "Israeli society" is an opinion, not a factual assertion that can be verified or debunked. The underlying death of Rachel Corrie — crushed by an Israeli military bulldozer in Gaza in 2003 while protesting home demolitions — is well-documented and not in dispute, though Israel's courts ruled it a "regrettable accident."

The Electronic Intifada's 2013 report provides the primary account of the pancake photos, and the Heritage House director's public response corroborates that the images existed and were intentional. Islam Times republished the story. However, the original Facebook post is no longer directly accessible in the evidence, and no mainstream or Israeli outlet independently covered the incident, limiting corroboration.

Key checks

  • Did soldiers post photos referencing 'Rachel Corrie pancakes'?: The Electronic Intifada reported in July 2013 that photos appeared on the Heritage House Facebook page showing soldiers with pancakes and a caption reading 'Afternoon of rachel corrie Pancakes and fun!' The settlement's director, Ben Packer, publicly defended the images.

  • Was this an organized 'party' or a single photo post?: The viral post describes 'pancake themed parties' (plural), suggesting multiple organized events. The available reporting describes a single Facebook photo post, not a series of celebrations.

  • Was Rachel Corrie killed by an Israeli bulldozer?: Rachel Corrie was killed on March 16, 2003, in Rafah, Gaza, when an Israeli military bulldozer crushed her while she protested home demolitions. This is well-documented by BBC, Wikipedia, and multiple sources, though Israel's courts ruled it an accident.

Confidence

Medium

Was this useful?

Your vote helps us see which fact-checks deserve more attention.

8 reviewed sources behind this verdict.

Might interest you next