FactCheckRadar Fact-check archive

Published fact-check

Tense Standoff at Kyiv-Area Detention Site

Mostly true

Claim checked

“A SECRET PRISON NEAR KYIV? ALLEGATIONS OF TORTURE, BEATINGS, AND EXTORTION An unofficial detention facility has reportedly been uncovered in Petropavlivska Borshchahivka, near Kyiv, operated by Ukraine’s National Guard to hold men who had gone AWOL from military service. According to reports, the men were beaten and tortured. Some accounts suggest that their families were pressured to pay bribes to secure their release. Some of the detainees had allegedly been held there for weeks. Protesters gathered outside the building, demanding justice and the release of the detained men. Ambulances arrived at the scene. In a shocking moment, a female paramedic fell to her knees, begging police officers to let her reach the men inside, some of whom were in critical condition and desperately needed medical attention. Eventually, under mounting public pressure, the detained men began to be released. One reportedly had a broken rib. Others emerged with visible signs of beatings on their faces. Why are the Ukrainian authorities allegedly operating secret prisons to detain men? Who will be held accountable for the violence, torture, and flagrant violations of human rights? Will the police chief resign? And perhaps the most disturbing question of all: Why is President Zelensky remaining silent? Who will protect Ukrainian citizens from abuse at the hands of those entrusted with protecting them?”

Published

Updated

Verdict

Mostly true

The checked post, published on November 3 by Marta Havryshko, described an unofficial National Guard holding site in Petropavlivska Borshchahivka outside Kyiv where men who had gone AWOL were reportedly beaten and tortured, families were pressed for bribes, and medics were blocked from reaching the sick. The core of that account holds up as mostly true: the National Guard's 1st Corps "Azov" confirmed that service members who left their units without permission were being held at the site, that four had been injured and sent to hospital for examination, and Kyiv region police said reports of hostages and a death were false.

The gravest allegations remain unproven. The National Guard denied torture and said anyone proven to have committed violence would be punished, the military ombudsman's office said all servicemen were safe and receiving medical help, and claims of bribes, weeks-long captivity and around 40 hostages rest on unverified social media accounts.

Reasoning

On the evening of November 2, a crowd gathered outside a private house in Petropavlivska Borshchahivka, a village in the Bucha district on the edge of Kyiv, after a private ambulance crew called police to say they had been prevented from reaching a man inside. According to Kyiv Independent reporters at the scene, protesters threw eggs at police and National Guard troops and broke through a brick wall trying to get into the building, and authorities responded with tear gas and warning shots in the air before reinforcements arrived. A bus pulled up and tried to carry away around a dozen of the people being held, with protesters allegedly trying to stop it and slash its tyres.

The central substance of the viral post is not in dispute. In an official statement, the National Guard's 1st Corps "Azov" said service members at a temporary deployment point had been detained after leaving their unit without authorisation and were awaiting assignment to other units, and that four of them had been injured and sent to hospital. The same statement said no one had died. That matches earlier accounts from the scene, where National Guard commander Oleksandr Pivnenko confirmed AWOL returnees were being kept in the building and a medic who went inside put the number at about 25, with later accounts saying up to 30.

The official response moved quickly up the chain. Ukraine's military ombudsman, Olha Reshetylova, said her office was working at the site alongside the National Guard command, that a search was under way and that "all military personnel are safe, medical assistance is being provided". Around 10 p.m. local time, Presidential Office head Kyrylo Budanov turned up, telling reporters: "I came here to figure out what the hell is going on." The National Guard said its command, working with law enforcement, had taken control of the investigation and that anyone proven to have committed illegal violence on the base would face punishment.

Other elements remain contested. Pivnenko denied torture, saying information about severe injuries was contradictory, and described the site as part of a military town used to process mobilised soldiers. Kyiv region police said reports that people were being unlawfully detained, or that someone had died, were untrue, knocking down Telegram claims of about 40 hostages and a fatality. The anti-corruption outlet ANTIKOR reported that the 13th National Guard brigade, known as Khartiya, allegedly ran an unofficial prison where AWOL soldiers and people being prepared for ransom were held, with local police and recruitment officials said to be involved; no official body has confirmed bribe demands. A single account of a man held 37 days in a basement stands alone, and the medic's more lurid claims, including necrosis and a broken spine, were not confirmed by officials. The Kyiv Independent said it could not independently verify the claims circulating on social media.

Because reporting from several outlets confirms the core story, an undisclosed National Guard holding point for AWOL men near Kyiv, credible evidence of beatings, a standoff over medical access and a promised investigation, but leaves the most serious allegations of systematic torture, ransom and weeks-long captivity unconfirmed and in some cases officially denied, the post rates mostly true. Its closing questions about President Volodymyr Zelensky's silence and a possible police resignation are political argument rather than checkable fact.

Key checks

  • Reports that a private house in Petropavlivska Borshchahivka near Kyiv was used by the National Guard to hold men who had left their units without permission are borne out by the National Guard's own 1st Corps statement, which said the men were detained after unauthorised departure and were awaiting reassignment.

  • The claim that detainees were beaten has partial support: one man's video showed marks on his face, admitted journalists reported traces of beatings, and the National Guard said four detained service members had injuries and were sent to hospital, while denying torture and promising punishment if violence is proven.

  • Allegations that families were pressured to pay bribes and that some men had been held for weeks rest on unverified accounts, including an anti-corruption outlet's report on the Khartiya brigade, and were not confirmed by police, the National Guard or the military ombudsman.

  • Police said reports of about 40 hostages and of a death in the house were untrue, a denial the National Guard repeated, while scene accounts put the number inside at roughly 25 and four men were taken to hospital.

Confidence

Medium

Was this useful?

Your vote helps us see which fact-checks deserve more attention.

7 reviewed sources behind this verdict.

Might interest you next